| 2017 |
Gary Lawson Sumner, Neville Rodda Victoria |
| 2016 |
Ali Forsyth Nelson, Neville Forsyth Stoke |
| 2015 |
Rob Ashton, Petar Sain Carlton Cornwall |
| 2014 |
Tony Grantham Birkenhead, Mike Nagy Taren Point |
| 2013 |
Ali Forsyth Havelock, Matt Gallop Blenheim |
| 2012 |
Blake Signal Stokes Valley, Alvin Gardiner Elmwood |
| 2011 |
Ryan Bester Cabramatta, Chris Le Lievre Onehunga |
| 2010 |
Gary Lawson Eastbourne, Dan Delany Onehunga |
| 2009 |
Rob Ashton Johnsonville, Ray Boffa Paraparaumu Beach |
| 2008 |
Gary Lawson, Andrew Curtain Eastbourne |
| 2007 |
Mike Kernaghan Onehunga, David Archer Taieri |
| 2006 |
Rex Holmes, Brian Howman Paraparaumu Beach |
| 2005 |
Kevin Robinson Tokoroa, Stephen Posa Takapuna |
| 2004 |
Mike Small, Kevin Gore Burnside |
| 2003 |
Vladimir Marsic, Petar Sain Carlton |
| 2002 |
Brendon Gibson, Grant Wakefield Johnsonville |
| 2001 |
Mike Galloway, David Clark Pakuranga |
| 2000 |
Chris Waterson Wanganui, Sean Johnson Aramoho |
| 1999 |
Philip Skoglund, Raymond Skoglund Northern |
| 1998 |
Peter Shaw, Russell Meyer Northern |
| 1997 |
Gary Lawson Belfast, Andrew Curtain Elmwood |
| 1996 |
Brian Baldwin, Gary Mounsey Paritutu |
| 1995 |
Peter Belliss Aramoho, Lance Tasker Castlecliff |
| 1994 |
Bruce McNish, Stewart Buttar Burnside |
| 1993 |
Sid Giddy Mt Maunganui, Kevin Asplin Arawa |
| 1992 |
Peter Belliss Aramoho, Robin Jefferson Poverty Bay |
| 1991 |
Nick Unkovich, Ross Haresnape Rawhiti |
| 1990 |
Bruce Malcolm, Gordon Duggie Port Chalmers |
| 1989 |
Dave Blanche, Jim Vevers Paraparaumu Beach |
| 1988 |
Jack Dale, Bruce McGowan Papanui |
| 1987 |
Peter Clark Whakatane, Don McKillop Opotiki |
| 1986 |
Les Morrison, Winston McLachlan Clinton |
| 1985 |
Maurice Symes, Geoff Hawken Hawera Park |
| 1984 |
Ivan Kostanich, Pat Robertson Helensville |
| 1983 |
Alan Crow New Plymouth RSA, Bruce Johns Paritutu |
| 1982 |
Danny O'Connor, Rowan Brassey Okahu Bay |
| 1981 |
Ian Dickison, Phil Dickison Kaikorai |
| 1980 |
Dave Burgess, Colin Galt Te Rangi |
| 1979 |
Bill MacArthur, Vern Muir Paritutu |
| 1978 |
George Alley, Cliff Pryce-Jones Mt Wellington |
| 1977 |
Norm Lash, Ted Quinn Hutt |
| 1976 |
Phil Skoglund, Mario Basile Northern |
| 1975 |
Dave Kydd, C W Franks Eastbourne |
| 1974 |
Kevin Darling, Ernie Wilson Balmacewen |
| 1973 |
Kevin Darling, R E Dunne Balmacewen |
| 1972 |
Phil Skoglund, Vic Sellars Northern |
| 1971 |
Dave Baldwin, John Murtagh Paritutu |
| 1970 |
Wally Wilkinson, H Hartley St Albans Merivale |
| 1969 |
Percy Jones, D Miller Otahuhu Railway |
| 1968 |
Hugh Hogg, A F Rawlinson St Clair |
| 1967 |
Percy Jones, D Miller Otahuhu Railway |
| 1966 |
E W Grimman, E M Wilson Caversham |
| 1965 |
Ces McGarry, Norm Lash Carlton |
| 1964 |
G P Ogilvie, Bill Scott Cromwell |
| 1963 |
John Flett, S W Jolly Pt Chevalier |
| 1962 |
Bob McDonald, Frank Livingstone Onehunga |
| 1961 |
M Vulinovich, N Posa Oratia |
| 1960 |
Pete Skoglund, Eddie Taylor Carlton |
| 1959 |
Hec Thompson, Gordon Bradley Whitiora |
| 1958 |
Ham Pirret, C J Rogers Tuakau |
| 1957 |
Lionel Franks, H Franks Balmoral |
| 1956 |
Life Ravenwood, L J Hughes North East Valley |
| 1955 |
Mate Borich, Rance Hawkins Hamilton |
| 1954 |
Charlie Spearman, N A McNab Christchurch RSA |
| 1953 |
Ted Pilkington, J F Benson Balmoral |
| 1952 |
Life Ravenwood, R K Aitchison North East Valley |
| 1951 |
Arthur Webster, George Littlejohn Hutt |
| 1950 |
E H Elwood, A Hirst Christchurch RSA |
| 1949 |
J G Mingins, Frank Livingstone Onehunga |
| 1948 |
S Garelja, M A Marinovich Oratia |
| 1947 |
Phil Exelby, Rance Hawkins Frankton |
| 1946 |
S C K Smith, G C Batchelor Northend |
| 1945 |
L Russell, J W Darroch St Heliers |
| 1944 |
E W Travers, P H Edwards St Kilda |
| 1941 |
Mort Squire, Harry Maslin Hawera |
| 1940 |
Bill Bremner, L G Donaldson West End Auckland |
| 1939 |
W J Robinson, J S Anchor Hamilton |
| 1938 |
C E Tyrrell, R B Clarke Roslyn |
| 1937 |
Jack Lowry, D Hunter Petone |
| 1936 |
H Haworth, J W Turpin Canterbury |
| 1935 |
R N Pilkington, H G Loveridge Hamilton |
| 1934 |
J A Veitch, J McPherson West Harbour |
| 1933 |
Mort Squire, Harry Maslin Hawera |
| 1932 |
C E Hardley, Bill Bremner West End Auckland |
| 1931 |
R N Pilkington, H G Loveridge Hamilton |
| 1930 |
H Jenkin, G L Gladding Carlton |
| 1929 |
F Laurenson, A G Kinvig Linwood |
| 1928 |
G Logan, D Dunphy Maitai |
| 1927 |
Max Walker, A Brakebush Auckland |
| 1926 |
E Tamblyn, W R Todd St Kilda |
| 1925 |
James Sexton, Charlie Davis Newtown |
| 1924 |
J A Redpath, Jas Angus Canterbury |
| 1923 |
T Edwards, W McCallum Temuka |
| 1922 |
James Brackenbridge, James Brackenbridge Newtown |
| 1921 |
S Potter, William Grenfell Wellington |
| 1920 |
W Spiller, J Turnbull Sydenham |
| 1919 |
W J Hueston, J B Rosemund Gisborne |
| 1918 |
Ernest Harraway, W M Hogg Dunedin |
| 1917 |
J J Martin, A Sawyer Turanganui |
| 1916 |
Chas Parata, V Dimock Thorndon |
| 1915 |
Alexander Smellie, George Blackwood Green Island |
| 1914 |
Ernest Harraway, J Johnson Dunedin |