| 2026 |
Adam Blucher, Brendon Walton, Richard Coles, Stefan McCartain Te Atatu Peninsula |
| 2025 |
Dan Dickison Tauranga, Alvin Gardiner Tauranga, Dave Jones Taupo, Terry Leadbetter Tauranga South |
| 2024 |
Darren Goodin, Dean Elgar, Rodger Hassall, Don Christensen Paritutu |
| 2023 |
Hamish Kape, Aidan Zittersteijn, Kaylin Huwyler, Daryl Read Paritutu |
| 2022 |
Craig De Faria, Steve Walker, Dave Wilson, Jordan Linn West End |
| 2021 |
Dan Dickison, Steve Hughes, John O'Shea, Lance Tasker Tauranga |
| 2020 |
Bruce Phillips, Scott Roberts, John Roberts, Mark Kuklinski Tower |
| 2019 |
Craig De Faria, Steve Walker, Dave Wilson, Jordan Linn West End |
| 2018 |
Brody Dix, Gary Dougherty, Keith Ansell, Adam Wishnoski New Lynn |
| 2017 |
Ces Bell, Fred Ellison, Ken Smith, Frank Grantham Taradale |
| 2016 |
Brian Little, Ian Monaghan, Ron Henn, Brian Henn Palmerston North |
| 2015 |
Darren Goodin, Rodger Hassall, Allan Batley, Bryan Sanger Paritutu |
| 2014 |
Stu Settle, Bruce Milne, John Settle, Kevin Smith Hinuera |
| 2013 |
Grant Anderson, Bruce Phillips, Mark Anderson, John Roberts Alton |
| 2012 |
Dan Delany Onehunga, Joe Whitelaw Onehunga, Mike Nasey Pakuranga, John Delany Te Papapa |
| 2011 |
Gary Lawson Eastbourne, Dan Delany Onehunga, Dave Good Onehunga, Gary Ruane Eastbourne |
| 2010 |
Iain Dalton, John Bush, Merv Gibbons, Tom Fisher Tauranga South |
| 2009 |
Gary Lilley, Noel Probyn, John Garrud, Keith Sampson West End |
| 2008 |
Gary Lilley, Noel Probyn, John Garrud, Keith Sampson West End |
| 2007 |
Dan Delany Onehunga, Gary Breckon Henderson, Mike Nasey Pakuranga, Mark Brown Pakuranga |
| 2006 |
Grant Anderson, Bruce Phillips, John Roberts, Mark Anderson Alton |
| 2005 |
Ray Park Wanganui, Clint Park Paraparaumu Beach, Craig Gush Northern, Barry Gush Northern |
| 2004 |
Philip Corney Aramoho, Ian Broderson Durie Hill, Kevin La Roche Aramoho, Dave Harris Aramoho |
| 2003 |
Russell Hardy, Graham Baxter, Grant Pease, John Gray Tower |
| 2002 |
John Granger, Bruce Stewart, Graeme Fulford, Dave Palmer Havelock North |
| 2001 |
Noel Alexander, Rick Day, Darren Redway, Roger Norton Rangiora |
| 2000 |
Mal Stewart, Gary Lilley, Keith Sampson, Noel Probyn West End |
| 1999 |
Dan Delany Rawhiti, Joe Whitelaw Rawhiti, Mike Nasey Bucklands Beach, Steve Bicknell Mangere |
| 1998 |
Mick Kennedy Vogeltown, Trevor Jury Vogeltown, Noel Krutz Smart Road, Gordon Armstrong Vogeltown |
| 1997 |
Brian Baldwin, Gary Mounsey, Don Christensen, Allan Batley Paritutu |
| 1996 |
Brian Fleming, David Bennett, Marty Martin, Des Griffin West End |
| 1995 |
Ian Budd Manaia, Des Mckenzie Kahutia, Bob Hills Kahutia, Kevin Hills Manaia |
| 1994 |
Murray Feek, Bryan Davis, Ken Walker, Mike Thomson Waimea |
| 1993 |
Brian Baldwin, Gary Mounsey, Mike Walsh, Allan Batley Paritutu |
| 1992 |
Ces Bell Aramoho, Dave Wooding Wanganui East, Cyril Evans Wanganui East, Trevor Brougham Aramoho |
| 1991 |
Terry Wilson, Peter Black, Ian Macdougall, Jim Reid Te Puke |
| 1990 |
Neville Sanger, Hori Johns, Larry Koorey, Mike Walsh Paritutu |
| 1989 |
Maurice Symes, John Earles, Rex Knox, Jim Madden Johnsonville |
| 1988 |
Graeme Henderson, Geoff Hawken, Jack Kennedy, Frank Hart Hawera Park |
| 1987 |
John Lambert, Peter Alty, Bruce Johns, Craig De Faria New Plymouth RSA |
| 1986 |
Bill MacArthur, Allen Robson, Ray Grylls, Vern Muir Paritutu |
| 1984 |
Rowan Brassey, Peter Thorne, Kevin Hickland, Barry Greer Okahu Bay |
| Barry Drabble, Trevor Smith, Graeme Waite, Lex Short Manurewa |
| 1981 |
John Lambert Tawa, Max Burgess Tawa Services, John Woods Tawa Services, Alex Daly Tawa |
| 1980 |
Murray George, John Lambert, Bill Lahood, Tony Spiller Seatoun |
| 1978 |
Ken Murtagh, Dave Baldwin, John Murtagh, Murray Fisher Paritutu |
| 1976 |
Murray Smith, Harry Nicholas, Dave Fleming, Mark Antunovich Taumarunui |
| 1975 |
Murray Smith, Harry Nicholas, Dave Fleming, Mark Antunovich Taumarunui |
| 1974 |
Doug Johnston, Tom Lynch, Merv Lansdown, Neville Bishop Rewa |
| 1972 |
Kevin Wing, Ted Everleigh, Colin Griggs, Bill Broughton Palmerston North |
| 1952 |
Ted Gee, Herb Brighting, Arthur Webster, George Littlejohn Hutt |
| 1951 |
Arthur Connew, Eddie Taylor, Herbert Neal, Bill Whittaker Carlton |
| 1950 |
Mort Squire, Louis Walsh, Charles Bathgate, William Hay Tower |
| 1949 |
Ted Gee, Herb Brighting, Arthur Webster, Robert Shearer Hutt |
| 1926 |
Alan Smart, John Griffin, William Freeman, Abraham Goldwater New Plymouth |
| 1925 |
Henry Price, Edward Dingle, John Bennett, Andrew Martin Fitzroy |
| 1924 |
Tom Billing, Ed Petty, Herbert Petty, Percy Douglass West End |
| 1923 |
Jimmy Lobb, Stephen Hurlestone, William Putt, William Bruce West End |