| 2025 |
Finbar McGuigan, Mike Carroll Stokes Valley |
| 2024 |
Finbar McGuigan, Mike Carroll Stokes Valley |
| 2023 |
Brendon Gibson, Wayne Coleman Johnsonville |
| 2022 |
Sar Alefosio, Robbie Yemm Naenae |
| 2021 |
Finbar McGuigan, Mike Carroll Stokes Valley |
| 2020 |
Graeme Corlett, Paul Rybinski Paekakariki |
| 2019 |
Sar Alefosio, Robbie Yemm Naenae |
| 2018 |
Logan Amer, Brady Amer Johnsonville |
| 2017 |
Rob Ashton, Brent Stubbins Johnsonville |
| 2016 |
Bruce Miller, Anton Ferrari Wilton |
| 2015 |
Raymond Martin Victoria, Marty Martin Island Bay |
| 2014 |
Lachlan Gordon Johnsonville, Seamus Curtin Plimmerton |
| 2013 |
Raymond Martin Victoria, Marty Martin Island Bay |
| 2012 |
Marc Geerlings, Roger Jones Stokes Valley |
| 2011 |
Richard Corry, Rhys Hakkens Victoria |
| 2010 |
Rob Ashton, Mark Noble Johnsonville |
| 2009 |
Robbie Bennett, Naki Nehemia Johnsonville |
| 2008 |
Rob Ashton, Mark Noble Johnsonville |
| 2007 |
Lou Newman Victoria, Adam Newman Eastbourne |
| 2006 |
Ken Brown, Adrian Cronin Johnsonville |
| 2004 |
Dean Stratford, Mickey Valasi Naenae |
| 2003 |
Ross Thorn, Eddie Irving Naenae |
| 2002 |
Mark Noble, Iain Opray Silverstream |
| 2001 |
Brian Radich, Tony Esposito Paraparaumu Beach |
| 2000 |
Domenico Massa, Vince Basile Island Bay |
| 1999 |
Mark Noble, Gil Lowry Central |
| 1997 |
Rob Ashton, Brendon Gibson Johnsonville |
| 1996 |
Rob Ashton, Bruce Henderson Johnsonville |
| 1995 |
Ken Blom, John Gray Wilton |
| 1994 |
Gil Lowry, Jim Madden Central |
| 1993 |
John Earles, Mark Cavanagh Wilton |
| 1992 |
Max Burgess, Brian Gundesen Tawa |
| 1990 |
Garrick Hamlyn, Ian Brennan Upper Hutt |
| 1989 |
John Leitch, Tony Hewitt Upper Hutt |
| 1988 |
Rod Leitch, Alan Child Upper Hutt |
| 1986 |
Gary Symons, Bert Volpe Naenae |
| 1985 |
Bert Evans, A Smith Paraparaumu Beach |
| 1984 |
Frank Gaudin, John Simpson Raumati |
| 1982 |
Eric Palmer, Joe Littler Wilton |
| 1981 |
Keith Arnold, Ron Payne Wilton |
| 1980 |
Earl Spencer, Ron Pilcher Naenae |
| 1978 |
John Lambert, Chas Miles Tawa |
| 1977 |
John Lambert, Ken Fisher Tawa |
| 1976 |
Harold Greenfield, Vern Bailey Central |
| 1974 |
Graham Galvin, Buzz Daniel Waikanae |
| 1973 |
Harold Greenfield, Vern Bailey Central |
| 1972 |
Sid Wood, Charlie Warr Johnsonville |
| 1970 |
Ron Graham, Norm Allen Wellington |
| 1969 |
Bill Hampton, Frank Tait Naenae |
| 1968 |
George Marsden, E C Minifie Miramar |
| 1967 |
Bill Hampton, Frank Tait Naenae |
| 1966 |
Harold Greenfield, Eric Hollier Central |
| 1965 |
Bill Newman, David Borlase Disabled Servicemen |
| 1964 |
Doug Turnbull, Stewart Wilson Hataitai |
| 1963 |
Bob Short, Tom McLoughlin Hutt |
| 1962 |
Fred Hofen, Charlie Warr Johnsonville |
| 1961 |
Jeff Barron, Errol Barron Miramar |
| 1960 |
Jock Baillie, Frank Diack Lyall Bay |
| 1959 |
Italo Cervo, Peter Menara Naenae |
| 1958 |
Fred Russell, Norm Lash Hataitai |
| 1957 |
Colin Simon, Buster Munro Woburn |
| 1956 |
Doug Turnbull, Ted Budd Hataitai |
| 1955 |
Alan Hutchison, D F Stuart Khandallah |
| 1954 |
Italo Cervo, E McIntosh Naenae |
| 1953 |
Bill Goodwin, Jim Goodwin Upper Hutt |
| 1952 |
Cliff McCawe, J Hutton Naenae |
| 1951 |
W Christian, W Peters Paekakariki |
| 1950 |
Bill Hadwin, George Littlejohn Hutt |
| 1949 |
Bill Hadwin, George Littlejohn Hutt |
| 1948 |
Arthur Connew, H Clarke Carlton |
| 1947 |
Arthur McIntyre, Mick Symons Otaki Railway |
| 1946 |
F H Fredericks, A Percy Karori |
| 1945 |
Roly Cometti, Doug Turnbull Hataitai |
| 1944 |
Jack Lawrie, W N Tucker Victoria |
| 1943 |
Bill Hadwin, Arthur McIntyre Hutt |
| 1942 |
J Conder, Syd King Lyall Bay |
| 1941 |
Oscar Silbery, R A Morris Petone |
| 1940 |
J H Wyatt, H F Harper Karori |
| 1939 |
W Gilbert, H L Dyett Karori |
| 1938 |
A Needham, R Thomson Karori |
| 1936 |
H Osborne, W J Hart Island Bay |
| 1935 |
Jack Lawrie, R E Craig Island Bay |
| 1934 |
Cyril Ingram, W E Osborne Wellington |