| 2020 |
Scott Evans, Rory Soden Mangere |
| 2019 |
Chris Lowe, Jordan King Mangere |
| 2018 |
Nick Thompson, Gary Cotton Mangere |
| 2017 |
Mike Galloway, Martin Dixon Hillsboro |
| 2016 |
Chris Lowe, Peter Thorne Hillsboro |
| 2015 |
Jordan King, Cairan MacElvanna Hillsboro |
| 2014 |
Gary Cotton, Mark Hall Mangere |
| 2013 |
Graham Growcott, Peter Hurle Blockhouse Bay |
| 2012 |
Neville Hill, Mike Bradshaw Avondale |
| 2011 |
Tom Delany, Jason Lindsay Onehunga |
| 2010 |
Dan Delany, Chris Le Lievre Onehunga |
| 2009 |
Dan Delany, Chris Le Lievre Onehunga |
| 2008 |
Doug Parlane, Colin O'Brien Onehunga |
| 2007 |
Paul Hickey, Ralph Pemberton Howick |
| 2006 |
Dan Delany, Chris Le Lievre Rawhiti |
| 2005 |
Neil Fisher, Gavin Brown Pakuranga |
| 2004 |
Gary Breckon, Steve Cox Henderson |
| 2003 |
Vladimir Marsic, Petar Sain Carlton |
| 2002 |
Wayne Wrack, Peter Walker Glen Eden |
| 2001 |
Mark Hall, Nick Botica Hillsboro |
| 2000 |
Mike Galloway, Gavin Brown Pakuranga |