| 2026 |
Dean Elgar, Kevan Sellers Paritutu |
| 2025 |
Craig De Faria, John Roberts West End |
| 2024 |
Steve Walker, Bruce Colgan West End |
| 2023 |
Craig De Faria, John Roberts West End |
| 2022 |
Craig De Faria, John Roberts West End |
| 2021 |
Scott Roberts, Mark Kuklinski Tower |
| 2020 |
Dean Elgar, Dave Wilson West End |
| 2019 |
Aidan Zittersteijn, John Zittersteijn Paritutu |
| 2018 |
Steve Walker, Jordan Linn West End |
| 2017 |
Craig De Faria, John Roberts West End |
| 2016 |
John Sexton, Martin Dravitzki West End |
| 2015 |
Darren Goodin, Peter Goodin Paritutu |
| 2014 |
Dean Elgar, Cameron Nairne West End |
| 2013 |
David Bennett, Dennis Osborne West End |
| 2012 |
Gary Lilley, John Garrud West End |
| 2011 |
Neville Elliott, Mike Curd Paritutu |
| 2010 |
Don Christensen, Ian Andrews Paritutu |
| 2009 |
Rodger Hassall, Neil Paterson Paritutu |
| 2008 |
Craig De Faria, Keith Sampson West End |
| 2007 |
Graham Baxter, Grant Pease Nolantown |
| 2006 |
Gary Lilley, Noel Probyn West End |
| 2005 |
Mal Stewart, John Sexton West End |
| 2004 |
Darren Goodin, Bryan Sanger Paritutu |
| 2003 |
Doug Bigham, Selwyn Lloyd Hawera Park |
| 2002 |
Peter Charteris, Barry Agnew Okato |
| 2001 |
Bruce Phillips, Tony Koubaridis Alton |
| 2000 |
John Bright, Allan White West End |
| 1999 |
Brian Baldwin, John Reid Paritutu |
| 1998 |
Brian Baldwin, John Reid Paritutu |
| 1997 |
Brian Baldwin, Gary Mounsey Paritutu |
| 1996 |
Don Christensen, George Taylor Avon |
| 1995 |
Brian Baldwin, Gary Mounsey Paritutu |
| 1994 |
Maurice Rowlands, Neil Paterson Paritutu |
| 1993 |
Ian Budd, Bill Johnston Manaia |
| 1992 |
Dave Baldwin, Brian Baldwin Paritutu |
| 1991 |
Maurice Rowlands, Neil Paterson Paritutu |
| 1990 |
Marty Martin, Alan Malloy Paritutu |
| 1989 |
Graham Baxter, Lane Thompson Kaponga |
| 1988 |
Bob Platt, John Half New Plymouth RSA |
| 1987 |
Dave Baldwin, Brian Baldwin Paritutu |
| 1986 |
Graeme Little, Mike Jacobsen Paritutu |
| 1985 |
John Lambert, Bruce Johns New Plymouth RSA |
| 1984 |
David Bennett, Des Griffin West End |
| 1983 |
Bruce Ballinger, Tom Macarthur Paritutu |
| 1982 |
Mick Eichstaedt, Pip Eichstaedt Inglewood |
| 1981 |
Bill MacArthur, Vern Muir Paritutu |
| 1980 |
Ray Stockman, Bruce Johns Paritutu |
| 1979 |
Bob Sinclair, Leo Perrett Opunake |
| 1978 |
Frank Burrell, Ross Elgar Vogeltown |
| 1977 |
Hugh Hamill, Harold Bishop Vogeltown |
| 1976 |
Jack Duckett, Syd Carley New Plymouth RSA |
| 1975 |
John Howie, Charlie Robinson Fitzroy |
| 1974 |
Ken Tompkins, Tom Macarthur Paritutu |
| 1973 |
Barney Spurdle, Bruce Johns Paritutu |