| 2025 |
Kirsten Edwards, Amy McIlroy Stoke |
| 2024 |
Jo Edwards, Val Smith Nelson |
| 2023 |
Jo Edwards, Val Smith Nelson |
| 2022 |
Jo Edwards, Val Smith Nelson |
| 2021 |
Barbara McGregor, Kristine Greaney United |
| 2020 |
Sheryl Riordan, Fiona Edwards Motueka |
| 2019 |
Katie Scott, Dianne Potts United |
| 2018 |
Amy McIlroy, Kirsten Edwards Stoke |
| 2017 |
Katie Scott, Dianne Potts United |
| 2016 |
Maureen Gibbons, Diane Hancock United |
| 2015 |
Margaret Eames, Rae Peterson Wakefield |
| 2014 |
Jo Edwards, Kirsten Edwards United |
| 2013 |
Marie Watson, Barbara Thomason Stoke |
| 2012 |
Marie Watson, Jo Collis Stoke |
| 2011 |
Amy McIlroy, Gemma Collett Stoke |
| 2010 |
Marie Watson, Jo Collis Stoke |
| 2009 |
Kay Tomlinson, Colleen Kempton Richmond |
| 2008 |
Kay Tomlinson, Colleen Kempton Richmond |
| 2007 |
Judy Heeman, Marie Watson United |
| 2006 |
Jo Edwards, Val Smith United |
| 2005 |
Maureen Gibbons, Helen Moseley Stoke |
| 2004 |
Judy Heeman, Lyn Rees Maitai |
| 2003 |
Judy Heeman, Pat Renison Maitai |
| 2002 |
Barbara McGregor, Marie Watson United |
| 2001 |
Jo Edwards, Val Smith United |
| 2000 |
Jenny Flemming, Pauline Harvey United |
| 1999 |
Jo Edwards, Val Smith United |
| 1998 |
Jo Edwards, Val Smith United |